9 04 2008

Trial under way in theft from disabled man

By Melody McDonald

Star-Telegram Staff Writer

April 9, 2008


Fort Worth — Johnny Bryant is mentally challenged. The 58-year-old man barely reads and can’t do math.

But when he was 18, prosecutors said, he found something he was good at: stocking groceries.

For the past four decades, Bryant has worked nights at area grocery stores. By the summer of 2002, prosecutors said, he had socked away $151,000 in his profit-sharing account with Winn-Dixie.

But, according to court testimony, he has nothing to show for it now.

Prosecutors contend that Cynthia Sue Hardee, 46, an Azle resident whose husband once worked with Bryant, swindled him out of his nest egg and spent it on cars, trailers, eyeglasses and even grooming for her dog.

Her attorney, Danny Burns, said that Hardee is not a thief and that she didn’t buy a single item without Bryant’s consent.

Hardee is on trial this week in state District Judge Mollee Westfall’s court on one count of theft of property. She is accused of stealing between $20,000 and $100,000 from Bryant. She is also charged with a count of misapplication of fiduciary property, accusing her of using Bryant’s money in a way that didn’t benefit him.

If convicted, she faces up to 10 years in prison.

Opening statements

On Tuesday morning, Tonya Harlan, who is prosecuting Hardee with Joe Shannon, told the jury of eight women and four men that Bryant was 16 when he got his first job at a Wyatt’s Cafeteria through a special-education program at Castleberry High School. When he was 18, he went to work as a stocker at Buddy’s grocery store.

“Even though he can’t read, he can tell this green-bean can matches that green-bean can,” Harlan said. “It is a good job for him.”

In 2002, Harlan said, Bryant was working at a Winn-Dixie in Azle when Brookshire’s acquired it. He had to decide what to do with the $151,000 in his profit-sharing account, she said.

Prosecutors say that Hardee, whose husband, Tim, was an assistant manager at the store, struck up a friendship with Bryant and persuaded him to cash out his account, which netted $111,275 after taxes and penalties.

Harlan said that Bryant and Hardee opened a joint checking account and that shortly thereafter, Hardee began writing checks.

“Every single penny is gone,” Harlan said. “The bank statements were sent to her house, and she wrote every single check on the account.”

During his opening statement Tuesday, Burns told the jury that Bryant, albeit slow, could understand and manage his life and finances.

He said that Bryant wanted to start a business with Hardee and that it was Bryant’s idea to take out his money.

Burns said that Hardee herself has mental and physical disabilities and that the two should have never tried to become entrepreneurs together. Still, he said, it was their choice.

“It was a disaster that these two people tried to go into business together, but they had the right to do this,” Burns said. “Each and every check was written after consulting with Johnny Bryant.”

Burns told the jury that Hardee and Bryant are good, honest people and that it was never Hardee’s intent to steal Bryant’s money.

“Cynthia Hardee is not a thief,” Burns said. “They had no clue what they were doing, but that doesn’t make it a crime.’

The witnesses

For much of the day, Bryant’s sister Jenny Bosley testified about his disability and about how she discovered he was broke. In December 2003, Bosley said, her brother ended up on her doorstep with his clothes in two trash bags.

“He had been evicted and had no other place to live,” she said.

On Jan. 3, 2004, Bosley, armed with copies of checks written by Hardee, went to Hardee’ home and confronted her about spending her brother’s money. Jurors saw some of those checks, which were used to buy vehicles, eyeglasses and guitars and to rent a big-screen television, among other things.

Some of the money went to Sean Trotter, who testified that Hardee gave him $8,500 to buy a dump truck and $15,000 to buy a trailer. He was supposed to use the equipment to help build Hardee and Bryant’s business, which he was told was going to be a resale shop.

Trotter said that time passed and Hardee never asked him to start the project but later told him that Bryant was out of money.

He testified that he didn’t realize Bryant was “slow” until months later, when he spent some time with him.

“I don’t believe he is on the same level as we are,” Trotter said, adding that he later gave his truck and trailer to Bryant so he could recoup some of his money. “I felt like Johnny had been taken advantage of.”




3 responses

10 04 2008
Trial under way in theft from disabled man By Melody McDonald Star …

[…] ganolen had a pretty good blog post. Definitely worth your time. Here is a small excerpt:Some of the money went to Sean Trotter, who testified that Hardee gave him $8500 to buy a dump truck and $15000 to buy a trailer. He was supposed to use the equipment to help build Hardee and Bryant’s business, which he was told was … […]

16 04 2008

this trial was over before it began. the jury was byast by having mentally challenged family members. also one of the jurrors knew one of the people involved in this trial. this was not a good example of our judicial system, or is it just how this country is ran? ponder on that a while. if it was your family would you want someone who has personal issues that cloud thier judgement?

16 04 2008

also, if he can’t read, write, or do math how did he enter and complete entrapenuer classes? also how did he manage to save 150,000 dollars if he didn’t do math? he played it on the stockmarket. you have to have some knowledge of these skills to accomplish these tasks. also was married twice with 3 kids? if he was so mentally challenged then where was his sister during this time or any of his family? why did he live by himself? how does he drive? you have to be able to read the signs to get to your destination!! this whole thing was a farse!!!!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: